Season 3, Episode 12
December 17, 2003
December 19, 2003
Ashley sneaks a peek at the Christmas gifts that she thinks Craig has bought for her, but is shocked when she sees Manny wearing them the next day. She confronts her, and they both realize that Craig has been lying to the both of them the whole time. When Craig and Ashley were supposed to sing together on stage, Ashley just sat on stage with her arms crossed. When Craig then asked what was wrong she slapped him and marched off the stage. Craig followed her to see what was going on, and she told him that she knew what was going on between Manny and him. They break up, and shortly after Manny comes over to tell him it was over between the two of them.
Joey realizes that the one he loves is Caitlin. He breaks up with Sydney, and tries to find Caitlin. He sees her boarding a plane and runs over there to stop her. Joey tells her that he wants her. She changed her mind—as to go—and stays and soon moves in with Joey.
- Spinner: "Well, one girlfriend down, one to go."
Craig: "Spinner, shut up."
Spinner: "Yes, Lord Stud."
- Craig: "You told her."
Manny: "No, no I didn't."
Craig: "Then how did she find out?"
Manny: Because you're stupid, Craig. You didn't think she'd find out about me. And you didn't think I'd find out.. about your lies."
- Joey: "It's not about Syndey, that's over. It's about you and me."