In #ButThatsNoneOfMyBusiness, Esme and Miles are searching the girls locker room for prescription pills. She says they're looking for someone who is uptight, she then asks if Miles has seen Shay's bag anywhere.
In #WorstGiftEver, Shay and Esme are both part of the girls Degrassi Cross Country team. Shay is upset that Esme is beating her during the practice run. When Shay gets her period, Esme makes snide comments about the incident. Shay is with Frankie in the girls locker room and plans to get back at Esme. During biology class Shay puts a red liquid on Esme’s seat to get back at Esme for embarrassing her and Esme yells at Shay for ruining her skirt. Shay later apologies to Esme and Esme gives her a box of diapers. Later Tiny congratulates Shay after the race, Esme makes a snide comment to Shay and Shay doesn't let it phase her.
In #WorstGiftEver, during a game of "Never Have I Ever", Esme decides to play "Truth or Dare", and dares Tiny to do seven minutes in heaven with Shay, but Shay feels uncomfortable doing it, so Esme dares Tiny to do it with Lola, asking Shay if she has a problem but Shay doesn't let Esme’s words get to her and allows Tiny and Lola to do it. Esme later makes comments to Shay that she isn't meeting Tiny's needs and how Shay thinks she’s better than her which causes Shay out of anger to call Esme easy and leaves.