In Fight for Your Right, he is interested in buying an mp3 player that Spinner stole from Jimmy.
In Tears Are Not Enough (2), he is seen at the beginning of the episode on the morning announcements, reminding everyone about the end-of-the-year Aloha dance.
In U Got the Look, Sully takes a liking to Manny when she starts dressing in sexier, more revealing attire and decides to ask her out on a date. He was also very rude to J.T. when he also attempts to ask Manny out. J.T. is crushed when Manny chooses Sully over him.
In Should I Stay or Should I Go?, Sully is confronted by Manny when she didn't receive a rose from him. He nonchalantly gives her back the rose she bought for him and tells her to "pretend it came from him". When Manny brings up the fact that Craig Manning bought a rose for his girlfriend Ashley Kerwin, Sully smugly says that Craig is a "sucker" and then walks away, leaving Manny disappointed. This episode was the last appearance of Sully.
In This Charming Man, Spinner mentions that their driving instructor didn't even let Sully take his driving test, and Paige says that he is a known dork.
- Sully was Manny's first boyfriend.
- Main article: Manny-Sully Relationship