- Jake Epstein as Craig Manning
- Miriam McDonald as Emma Nelson
- Daniel Clark as Sean Cameron
- Stacey Farber as Ellie Nash
- Aubrey Graham as Jimmy Brooks
- Mike Lobel as Jay Hogart
- Cassie Steele as Manny Santos
- Adamo Ruggiero as Marco Del Rossi
- Deanna Casaluce as Alex Nuñez
- Lauren Collins as Paige Michalchuk
- Shane Kippel as Spinner Mason
- Sarah Barrable-Tishauer as Liberty Van Zandt
- Stefan Brogren as Archie Simpson (voice)
The mini shows bloopers of the actors messing up their lines from the following minis: What if Craig Picked Emma, Don't You Forget About Me, Man in the Mirror, Bizarre Love Triangle, Hey Ladies, Bigmouth Strikes Again, Notorious, The Lovecats, What If Jimmy Was Never Shot, What if Emma Was Jay and Jay Was Emma, and What if Liberty was Paige and Paige Was Liberty.
- Emma: "But I think I'm pregnant."
Craig: "..... Awkward."